Shabbat Toldot: Two Nations Struggle to Be Born

The poetry of life, and its karma (if you’ll permit the cross-cultural expression), are everywhere if one is alert to the signs. In this week’s parashah we read of the difficulty our mother Rivkah experienced in pregnancy: as the oracle she consulted told her,

שְׁנֵ֤י גוֹיִם֙ בְּבִטְנֵ֔ךְ וּשְׁנֵ֣י לְאֻמִּ֔ים מִמֵּעַ֖יִךְ יִפָּרֵ֑דוּ וּלְאֹם֙ מִלְאֹ֣ם יֶֽאֱמָ֔ץ וְרַ֖ב יַעֲבֹ֥ד צָעִֽיר

Two nations are in your womb, two separate peoples shall issue from your body; one people shall be mightier than the other, and the older shall serve the younger. (Genesis 25.23)

Our ancestors identified the twins about to be born, Esau and Jacob, with Edom and Israel. Edom was an ancient cousin and enemy of the people of Israel, and the enmity, at least according to our parashah, was based in the simple fact that Esau wanted to murder Jacob for stealing the blessing of the firstborn. Rivkah knew that the blessing was meant to be Jacob’s and so she engineered the theft, as the Torah records.

The Sages identify Edom with the empire of Rome, then Christianity: cousins and enemies. Complicating the picture is Rashi’s medieval apologetic explaining that Jacob actually was firstborn and so the blessing really should have been his (our greatest Torah commentator was no obstetrician: he explained that first conceived would naturally be last out, as if the uterus was a tube).

What’s significant about the story of this birth is that the struggle to become oneself is inextricably bound up with another person and their own effort to become. This week’s attempt at a solution (theft) works out no better than that tried by Abraham and Sarah when they threw Hagar and Ishma’el out of the house. The Jewish philosopher Emanuel Levinas may have been inspired by this idea when he taught that once one becomes aware of an Other, one is commanded by that Other in becoming oneself.

Crossing the divide between before life and life seems fated to be a struggle, from chrysalis to eggshell to uterine contractions. Becoming a human being and discovering, much less fulfilling, the shape of one’s potential is no arduous – I’ve made it a point more than once to look a teenager in the eye and tell them to hold on, that it gets better in your twenties.

Exploring and developing the promise of any birth is hard work. Right now in the aftermath of Israeli elections, the work to build a governing coalition requires much effort: there must be a balancing between promises made, principles held, and compromises demanded. The rhetoric in some circles is shockingly harsh, and that is perhaps the best barometer of the possibilities of this moment. Israelis who seek co-existence insist that only a coalition composed of Jews and Arabs can truly be a government of change toward peace. But on both sides, there are Palestinians and Israelis who do not trust. After so many years of brutalization, they do not believe that peace is possible with co-existence.

In this small and very intense place at the eastern edge of the Mediterranean Sea, two peoples struggle within one womb to be born. They are connected from birth, and it seems that our own Torah is telling us that this is our existential reality: we are born together.

The work of being born is not easy, for an individual or for a people. As much as the average Irsaeli might wish it otherwise, the way forward is with their neighbors, not in spite of and not without. In the same way, we who live in the US will never know a path clear of the kind of complication that comes with sharing the world with others, including those with whom we have always struggled. What have we stolen from them, and what have they taken from us, and will we find our way toward Esau’s forgiving embrace or Jacob’s enduring paranoia?

Leave a Reply